Portugal - HEAL-Link

Report
Click to edit Master title style
•
•
•
•
•
Click to edit Master text styles
Second level
Third level
Fourth level
Fifth level
Preservation Program
Southern European Libraries Link
FCCN, 3 June 2011
João Mendes Moreira
Click to edit Master title
Agenda
style
••
•
••
•
•
•
Click
to edit
Master
text styles
Scope
and
goals
Second level
Existing
Third level solutions
Fourth level
Comparative analisys
Fifth level
• Conclusions
• Recomendations
Click to edit Selection
Master title
criteria
style
•
••
•
•
•
•
•
Click to edit Master text styles
Terms
and
conditions
Second level
Third level
Consortium/Member support
Fourth level
Fifth level
Contents (vendors, titles e temporal coverage)
• Costs (subscription and support/maintenance)
Click to edit
Existing
Master solutions
title style
•
••
•
••
•
Click to edit Master text styles
Local
loading
Second level
Third level
LOCKSS
Fourth level (Lots of Copies
Fifth level
Keeps Stuff
Safe)
• CLOCKSS (Controlled LOCKSS)
• PORTICO
Click to edit Master title style
•
•
•
•
•
Click to edit Master text styles
Second level
Third level
Fourth level
Fifth level
Detailed
Comparative analysis
Click toTerms
edit Master
and conditions
title style
• Click
to edit MasterLOCKSS
text styles
Situação
•A biblioteca
Secondcancela
levela
e precisa
manter
•subscrição
Third
level
SIM
o acesso aos conteúdos até
subscritos level
•entãoFourth
periódico deixa de estar
•Odisponível
Fifthatravés
level
SIM
do editor
O editor cessa
actividade
a sua
Situação de catástrofe que
conduz à falha dos
servidores do editor
Falha
temporária
dos
servidores do editor
CLOCKSS
PORTICO
NÃO
SIM
SIM
SIM
SIM
SIM
SIM
SIM
SIM
SIM
SIM
NÃO
NÃO
Click to edit Master Contents
title style
Editores
•
•
•
•
•
ACM
ACS
AIP
ANNUAL REVIEWS
CUP
EBSCO
ELSEVIER
EMERALD
IEEE
IOP
RSC
SAGE
SIAM
SPRINGER
TAYLOR & FRANCIS
WILEY-BLACKWELL
WOK
Total Sim
WEB SITE
x
LOCAL LOAD







x






x


88%
Click to edit Master text styles
?
Second level 

Third level
NA

Fourth level

Fifth level






?
53%
LOCKSS
x
x
x

x
NA
x

x



x
CLOCKSS



x
NA

x
x



x


PORTICO
x




NA









NA
35%
NA
53%
NA
82%
Click to edit Master Contents
title style
LOCKSS
EDITORES B-ON
CLOCKSS
Participating Post-cancellation Participating
X
X
• ACSClick to edit Master
text
X
Xstyles
X
X
• AIP
Second
level
AR
S
S
S (1 tit)
X
• BLACKWELL
Third
level
CUP
X
X
X
X
• ELSEVIER
Fourth
level
EMERALD
S
S
• IEEEFifth level
X
X
ACM
IOP
NATURE
RSC
SAGE
SIAM
SPRINGER
T&F
WILEY
Participam
Não Participam
% de editores b-on participantes
S
X
S
S
X
X
S
S (1 tit)
6
11
35%
S
X
S
S
X
X
S
X
6
11
35%
Portico
Participating
Local
Post-cancellation Loading
S
X
S
X
S
X
S
X
X
S
S
S
X
S
S
S
X
X
X
X
X
X
S
S
X
S
S
S
S
X
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
X
X
S
S
X
S
S
S
S
X
9
8
53%
14
3
82%
8
9
47%
Acesso
Online
S - gratis
X
S - gratis
X
S - gratis
S
S - gratis
X
S - Pago
S
X
S - gratis
S - Pago
X
S (parcial) Pago
S
S - gratis
S
X
S
S - Pago
X
S - Pago
X
S - Pago
X
S
S - Pago
X
S
S - Pago
S
12
3
71%
9
7
53%
Click to edit MasterTitles
title style
b-on
Títulos b-on
•
•
•
•
•
Títulos b-on: preservação
Click to edit Master
text styles
Títulos
Editoras
Second level 37%
Títulos EBSCO
Third63%level
Fourth level
Fifth level
Títulos
Editoras
37%
23%
Títulos EBSCO
63%
Títulos preservados editoras b-on
Títulos
editoras
Preservados
Títulos
Preservados
61%
Click to edit Master title style
•
•
•
•
••
Click
Master
text
styles
23% toofedit
b-on
titles
are
preserved by Portico (this
figure
tends
Second
levelto increase).
Third level
Fourth level
This
percentage doesn’t include:
Fifth level
• EBSCO aggregator (63%) titles
• IEEE and ACM proceedings and standards
• From the 7. 000 available titles, 4.376 are in
Portico (61% of subscribed titles).
Click toTOP
edit 10
Master
- Preservation
title style
Editor
Preservado PRTC c/
PCA
Springer
Sim
ACM
Não
IEEE
Não
Elsevier
Sim
Nature
Sim
Elsevier
Sim
ACS
Não
Biomaterials
Elsevier
Sim
Journal of Chromatography A
Elsevier
Sim
The Lancet (British Edition)
Elsevier
Sim
Título
•
•
•
•
•
Wireless Networks
Click
to edit Master text styles
Proceeding
Second
level
3DTV Conference, 2007
Third
Journal level
of Sound and Vibration
Nature level
Fourth
Food Chemistry
Fifth
level
Journal of the American Chemical Society
7 out of 10 top 10 are preserved by portico with PCA
Click to edit
FinalMaster
considerations
title style
••
•
•
•
•
Click
Master
text styles
Localto– edit
solution
to much
expensive; need to allocate HR
Second level
and IT
Third level
CLOCKSS
Fourth level - solution is not suitable since does not
Fifth
level
support
post-cancellation
• LOCKSS – suitable terms and conditions but bad
content coverage
• Portico – solution more suitable with better coverage
and terms and conditions
Click to edit Master
Conclusions
title style
•
•
••
•
•
Theretoisedit
Click
no single
Master solution
text styles
that grants preservation to
all
contents
Second
leveldue to their typology and nature.
Third
Locallevel
hosting despite its content coverage and terms
Fourth
level
and conditions
potential its not suitable for b-on due to
development
and operation costs
Fifth level
• B-on contents include a big rate of titles provided by
aggregators that are not eligible for preservation
• Referential databases are also not eligible for
preservation
Click to edit Master
Conclusions
title style
•
••
•
••
•
Click to edit Master text styles
Portico
seams to be the most suitable solutions
Second level
Third level
There
are contents that are not dealt by this
Fourth level
Fifth level
service
• There are limitations at the access level
Click to edit Recomendations
Master title style
••
•
••
••
•
Click
to edit
Master text styles
Adopt
Portico
Second level
Continue
to
follow
preservation
initiatives
Third level
Establish
international partnerships in
Fourth level
Fifth levelto promote local hosting solutions
order
and share of services and costs
• Make pressure of vendors in order to
foster their participation on preservation
initiatives

similar documents