Karim Karzazi, AXA Matrix Risk Consultants, France

Report
Risk Consulting
REVISION TO EN 12 845 and CEA 4001
EFSN – MAY 2014
REVISION TO EN 12 845 and CEA 4001
Do you think our sprinkler standards are so complicated?
REVISION TO EN 12 845 and CEA 4001
1: Current status of EN 12 845 – revision 1
2: revision 2 of EN 12845
3: CEA 4001- new edition 2013
4: CEA 4001 expected modifications
Current status of EN 12 845 – revision 1
Current version :
June 2009 Includes amendments A1 and A2
Revision 1 of EN 12 845
Includes ESFR, CMSA, excessive clearance, test
line, electrical cables, K factor >115, third party
inspection, new annex F…)
prEN 12845 rev 1 had a UAP draft dispatched to
CCMC on 2013/12/18 (stage 30.99),
the next stage will be the submission to UAP
(formal vote yes/no) by 2014/05/22
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845
 New structure of document : 27 chapters distributed in 6 sections
SECTION 1: SCOPE, REFERENCES and DEFINITIONS
SECTION 2 : HAZARD EVALUATION
SECTION 3 : DESIGN CRITERIA
SECTION 4 : INSTALLATION
SECTION 5 : WATER SUPPLY
SECTION 6 : COMMISSIONING AND CONTROL PROGRAMME
Annexes
Draft expected S2-2014
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
SECTION 1: SCOPE, REFERENCES and DEFINITIONS
 Introduction enabling new technologies not included
 Scope more precise to avoid conflict especially with residential
sprinkler standard
 More comprehensive set of definitions
 Will include contract, planning and documentation
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
SECTION 2 : HAZARD EVALUATION
 New HHS 5 to take into account plastic goods
 Classification will differentiate: manufacturing / nonmanufacturing.
 Classification for manufacturing will include additional parameters
to define hazard :
Fire Hazard : FH1, FH2, FH3 or FH4
Will be detailed in the next presentation (Stuart Lloyd)
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
SECTION 3 : DESIGN CRITERIA
 Design density and area of operation linked to hazard class + ceiling
height
 Design section for storage will include existing and new protection
tables + new HHS 5 classification.
 Will cover the former special risk annex G (flammable liq, hanging
garments, aerosols...)
 Storage configuration STC1 to STC6 will remain similar as today
 ESFR and CMSA will be as separate chapters
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
SECTION 4 : INSTALLATION
No big modification but many improvements and precisions of
existing text :
 dry system,
 more details about specific areas like stairways, concealed spaces..
 location from beams,
 Sprinkler above suspended ceiling. 9 m² for hollow spaces > 0.3 m and < 0.5
m…,
 Clarification about location of in-rack sprinkler
 Special rack configuration included
 Corrosion issues
 Electrical issues: more details provided especially regarding alarms
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
SECTION 5 : WATER SUPPLY
 Connection for other service : hydrants 90m3/h in OH and 120 m3/h
in HH.
 Detailed requirements for pump room and alarm valve room
 Velocity in the suction pipe increased to 2,5 m/s for suction lift
condition and 4m/s for positive head : cost effective modification
 Specific requirements for diesel equipped with Electronic Fuel
Management Control (ECM)
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
Section 5 : water supply
 Volume of tank no longer based on Qmax: reduction of tank volume;
based on unfavourable area.
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
SECTION 6 : COMMISSIONING AND CONTROL PROGRAMME
 Contract , planning and documentation: simplification with
suppression of preliminary design stage
 Flushing of pipework
 Detail procedure for commissioning and first inspection to be be
witnessed by the authorities or a third party inspection body
accepted by the authorities
 Model of maintenance report provided : complete list of all
maintenance operation for each component
 Model of commissioning and inspection report provided
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : KEY POINTS
SECTION 6 : COMMISSIONING AND CONTROL PROGRAMME
 Detailed user’s control programme
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845
Annexes
All references to pre-calculated system suppressed from
main body of the text
Specific annex (stand alone) covers all the requirements
for pre-calculated system (FH1 and FH2)
Number of annexes reduced
Comprehensive annex for new technologies detailing
process to accept them
Future revision 2 of EN 12 845 : conclusion
Even if many modifications are expected:
Standard should be simple to understand and to
apply: more flow charts and graphics
Installation should not be more expensive than
today (even less: e.g. tank volume…)
A large range of technology (K factor, type of
sprinklers…) should be possible
CEA 4001- new edition 2013
First published in 1996
Latest edition August 2013
Includes all the proposals drafted
since 2009:
New concept for rack protection
(multiple row, >3,2m wide…)
Protection of rubber tyres
Update classification of goods
involving plastic
Sprinkler in freezers
Suction chambers
…
CEA 4001: expected modifications
Future Update planed for end of 2014-beginning 2015
Main modifications will concern:
Full revision of chapter 15 : pipework
Total revision of Annex L : ESFR
New annex for CMSA
CEA 4001: expected modifications
revised chapter 15 : pipework
Include requirements for plastic pipe, press fitting pipe system,
flexible pipe, stainless steel…
Detailed requirements for pipe thickness and pipe assembly
Table T 15.2.2.2 minimum wall thickness for steel pipes (draft)
NF EN 10
217–1
EN 10 255 –
type M
EN 10 216 –
1
EN 10 217 –
1
DN 25
1"
DN 32
1"1/4
DN 40
1"1/2
DN 50
2"
DN 65
2"1/2
DN 80
3"
DN 100
4"
DN 125
5"
DN 150
6"
DN 200
8"
DN 250
10"
DN 300
12"
DN 350
14"
DN 400
16"
DN 450
18"
DN 500
20"
* 165,1 for EN 10255
External Ø
NF EN 10
255 –type L
Nominal diameter
Threaded pipes and cut grooved
NF EN 10
216-1
Roll grooved or welded
33,7
42,4
48,3
60,3
76,1
88,9
114,3
139,7
168,3*
219,1
273
323,9
355,6
406,4
457
508
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,9
3,2
3,6
4
4,5
5
5,6
5,6
6,3
6,3
6,3
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,9
3,2
3,6
4
-
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,6
2,6
3,2
3,6
4
4,5
4,5
5
5,6
5,6
6,3
6,3
6,3
3,2
3,2
3,2
3,6
3,6
4
4,5
5
5
-
3,2
3,2
3,2
3,6
3,6
4
4,5
5
5
6,3
6,3
7,1
8
8,8
10
11
3,2
3,2
3,2
3,6
3,6
4
4,5
5
5
6,3
6,3
7,1
8
8,8
10
11
CEA 4001: expected modifications
Total revision of Annex L : ESFR
Similar to EN 12845 revision 1
Will include latest update especially regarding
limitation for K14 (K200) ESFR heads
New annex for CMSA
Similar to EN 12845 revision 1
Ambition of CEA 4001: to be pro-active and up
to date standard thanks to faster procedure
than CEN
Contact
Thank you
Karim KARZAZI
Technical Board Manager
AXA MATRIX Risk Consultants
2-4, rue Jules Lefebvre - 75009 Paris – France
(+33) 6 78 88 24 69
[email protected]

similar documents