CPS Practices and Policies: NCANDS Data Now and in the Future

Report
CPS Practices and Policies:
NCANDS Data Now and
in the Future
Children’s Justice Act Grantee
State Liaison Officer Meeting
June 21, 2011
p2
Today’s Presentation
• CAPTA update
• Highlights from recent analyses of National
Child Abuse and Neglect Data System
(NCANDS) data
• Contemporary issues of reporting and
conducting CPS responses:
– Implementation and reporting of alternative response
– Expansion of data collection on fatalities and near
fatalities
p3
FFY 2009 Data
• 52 States reported data
(including DC and PR):
– 50 States submitted Child Files
and Agency Files
– 2 States submitted aggregateonly data
• Report link
http://www.acf.hhs.gov/programs/cb/pubs/cm09/index.htm
p4
Screening and Response
CPS agencies have a two-stage process for child
maltreatment allegations:
Stage 1: Screening
• Nationally estimated 3.3 million referrals were received
by CPS agencies
– Including an estimated 6.0 million children.
Stage 2: CPS response in the form of an investigation
response or alternative response
• 52 States reported 2.0 million referrals received a CPS
response including
– 3.6 million duplicate children.
– 3.0 million unique children.
Report Sources 2005-2009
• For FFY 2009:
– Professionals submitted more than one-half of reports.
– Nonprofessionals submitted nearly 30%.
– “Other” and unknown submitted nearly 14%.
p5
p6
CPS Response
• Investigation response
• Alternative or differential response
In NCANDS, the term disposition is used for both
investigation and alternative responses, for the
determination or finding related to the CPS
response.
p7
Report Dispositions 2009
• One-quarter of all
reports included
one or more
victims of
maltreatment
• N=52 States
Alternative Response:
Current Definition
• The provision of a response other than an
investigation that did (AR victim) or did not
(AR nonvictim) determine that any child in the
report was a victim of maltreatment. The term
differential response is sometimes used.
p8
Alternative Response:
Current Status
• NCANDS recognizes alternative response as a
type of CPS response after a referral has been
screened in.
• About 10 percent of CPS responses (9.2% of
reports 8.6% of children) include screened-in
alternative response.
• We have two categories for AR: AR nonvictim and
AR victim
– 11 States report using only AR nonvictims
– 2 States report AR victim and AR nonvictims
– 1 State reports AR victims only
p9
p10
Alternative Response: Discussion
• Does this group suggest using a term different
from alternative response?
• In the future, does this group suggest
analyzing AR separately from IR (investigation
response), and if so, to what extent?
• Should we continue to have the two categories
of AR victims and AR nonvictims?
p11
Child Victims
• NCANDS victim: a child for whom the State
determined at least one maltreatment was
substantiated or indicated and a disposition of
substantiated, indicated, or alternative response
victim was assigned.
• Duplicate count:
– 52 States reported
– Rate 10.1 per 1,000 children
– National estimate 763,000 duplicate victims
• Unique count:
– 50 States reported
– Rate 9.3 per 1,000 children
– National estimate 702,000 unique count of victims
p12
Unique and Duplicate Counts
• Duplicate: Counting a child each time that he or
she was a subject of a report that received a CPS
response. This count is also known as a reportchild pair.
• Unique: Identifying and counting a child once,
regardless of the number of reports that received
a CPS response.
• Increasingly we use unique counts to
describe children, but in some instances
need to continue to use duplicate counts,
which are tied to each report.
p13
Disposition and Victimization Rates
• Number and rate of victims have been decreasing
regardless of unique or duplicate counts.
p14
Victim Demographics
• One-third (33.4%)of all child victims were younger
than 4 years.
– 12.6% younger than 1 year
– Unique count N=50 States
• Eighty-seven percent of victims were comprised of
three races or ethnicities.
–
–
–
–
44.0% White
22.3% African-American
20.7% Hispanic
Unique count N=49 States.
• Three-quarters (78.3%) of victims suffered neglect.
– A child may have suffered more than one type of
maltreatment.
– Unique count. N=50 States
P15
All Victims by Risk Factors 2009 (unique count)
Reported
Domestic Violence
Disability
Caregiver Risk Factor
• 11% of unique victims
• 18.3% of victims had a
were reported as having
caregiver risk factor of
a disability:
domestic violence.
– 3.5% percent had some
other medical condition
not specifically identified
– 2.9% behavior problems
– 2.1% percent of victims
were emotionally
disturbed.
– N=42 States
– N=38 States
• 6.5% of nonvictims had
a caregiver risk factor of
domestic violence.
– N=36 States
p16
Fatalities
• The number of fatalities have been increasing
during the past 5 years.
• FFY 2005
– 51 States
– Rate 1.94 per 100,000 children
– national estimate 1,450
• FFY 2009
– 49 States
– Rate 2.34 per 100,000 children
– national estimate 1,770
• Even small fluctuations in the data can affect the
national estimate and national rate.
• We may see slight decrease for FFY 2010.
Maltreatment Types
A child fatality may have suffered from more than one type
of maltreatment so two analyses were conducted.
Analyzing children by mutually
exclusive maltreatments:
Analyzing all maltreatments:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
N/A multiple maltreatments
66.7 % neglected
44.8% physically abused
21.1% other
9.8% medically neglected
1.9% sexually abused
1.2% psychologically maltreated
Total =145.8%,
N=44 States, 1,343 fatalities
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
36.7% multiple maltreatments
35.8% neglected
23.2% physically abused
2.0% other
1.8% medically neglected
0.4% sexually abused
0.1 psychologically maltreated
Total= 100.0%
N=44 States, 1,343 fatalities
17
P18
Fatalities: Discussion
• We are considering asking States if they can
provide data on:
– Date of death
– Which agency has determined that the death is due to
child abuse or neglect
– Which cases are near fatalities?
• We are also increasing the number of analyses
related to fatalities.
• Advice, concerns, related to fatalities and near
fatalities?
p19
FFY 2012
• Child Maltreatment 2010 will be released December 2011
– Currently in the design and production phase
– Plan is to expand analyses from 51 to 56 tables
– Unique counts will continue to have a large role in the
report
– Alternative responses will have greater visibility in the
report
• New application to OMB will be submitted April 2012.
p20
Additional Input
• Any additional
– Questions?
– Comments?
– Discussion items?
p21
Contact Information
• Your input is appreciated. Please send ideas or
suggestions to:
Dr. John A. Gaudiosi
[email protected]
OR
Madonna Aveni
[email protected]

similar documents